It’s really hard to follow the show when I’m watching it on my computer, plus, since that annoys me in general, I’ve only watched both eps once. But, in the books, Murphy knows Harry is a real wizard. Does the TV show version of her not know that? Is that what the significance of the final scene of ep 2 was?
Published by Nancy E. Shaffer
NANCY E. SHAFFER has been an experimental psychologist (M.A., Cognitive Psychology, Rice University), a philosopher (Ph.D., History and Philosophy of Science, University of California, Davis), and software developer. She taught history and philosophy of science at Concordia University in Montreal, Quebec and the University of Nebraska Omaha.
Her philosophical work has appeared in the journal Philosophy of Science and her pop-culture philosophy website, All Things Philosophical on Buffy the Vampire Slayer and Angel: the Series.
Dis/inhbition is her first novel.
She currently resides in Tempe, Arizona.
View all posts by Nancy E. Shaffer
21 thoughts on “Dresden Files TV show question”
Ep 2! I knew I was supposed to watch something yesterday.
I’m confused with just the first ep, but mostly due to: a) the first ep aired not being the first ep on the timeline and b) no book background. And maybe the fact I just got the eps because of Terrence Mann.
Um…who’s Terrence Mann?
They’re holding that in the “vague but possible” zone, it seems. She doesn’t ask the questions that she should if she didn’t know, but they haven’t addressed it directly.
My theory is that they are trying to show her as knowing, but extremely uncomfortable with the idea, so they don’t really talk about how he does things, or why certain things have happened. Is the book version nothing like that?
It’s been a long time since I read the first book, but it seems to me Murphy not only knew from the beginning of the book series, she also worked in a special branch of the police department that unofficially investigated supernatural crimes and so had Harry on retainer as a consultant.
He’s playing the ghost in the Dresden Files (y’know the white-haired fellow with the snooty accent), but he’s a big Broadway star. Original cast in a lot of great shows like Cats, Les Miserables and Scarlet Pimpernel.
The original Broadway Beast. I’ve heard mixed reviews of his live performances, but he’s fantastic on the cast recording.
Oh yes, the TV show’s version of Bob.
Ah. OK. Thanks.
Hey, I only saw the first episode so far. Is SciFi putting them all on the internet?
You’re right on that bit, Masq — although she did bring Harry in to consult on the first corpse of Ep 2 and they do seem to have a working relationship, so maybe Darby’s got it after all?
The only solution is to re-watch a few times. Which I don’t want to do on my computer, because then I can’t use my computer for like, an hour, and I lapse into catatonic schitzophrenia.
hmm you know I’ve only seen them once myself and I’ll be damned if i can remember if Murphy on the TV version knows he’s a wizard. I’ll assume she knows SOMETHING since he is still her consultant
Sci-Fi reruns them ad nauseum. if you get that channel, you can see it on the tv
It’s just that last speech in the final scene of ep 2 that confused me.
Ah, well then that would be a problem. if i get bored during test making I’ll see if i cna watch it for you but in ep 2 it didn’t seem like she knew oh so much but knew enough to know he was lying about doing something to her
yeah i know
That’s the impression I got, too.
Can answer some of this.
The Murphy in the books is different than the one in the series. In the books, Murphy’s dad is dead and was amongst the first cops to deal with the paranormal – he got killed because of the paranormal. Murphy also does not have any children. But is divorced. Her ex has custody.
In the series – Murphy’s Dad took off with a lover to Florida, and Murphy has one kid.
I think in both this episode and the books, she knows he’s a wizard but doesn’t know the extent of what he can do. In the books, she saw him as
a bit of a specialist on paranormal and in Storm Front, thought like everyone else he might be the bad guy.
In the series – I know from the podcasts on http://www.jimbutchernews.com- they are going to do an adaptation of Storm Front – but I think it comes about six episodes in. Which means they are covering the period of time in the Murphy/Dresden relationship leading up to Storm Front. So that may explain why she doesn’t seem to know as much about him as she does in the book version.
From what I’ve seen so far and what I’ve read and heard online both from Jim Butcher and the creators, the television series is not going to closely follow the books. And is in some respects a looser interpretation. Butcher did however have input and the main things have been kept the same. Murphy/Dresden relationship. Bob/Dresden relationship. Dresden’s background with his parents. And who Dresden is, and Dresden’s relationship with the High Council (in the books White Council). What’s been changed is his staff (now a hockey stick), some of Murphy’s background, and who Justin was.
I’ve been watching the episodes with the veiw that they probably won’t follow the story in the books, but as long as I like Harry and he fits how I viewed him in the books? I’m fine with it. So far, so good. 😉
I’ve read all the books, I’m familiar with them. Which is why I have questions about where the TV show seems to be different.
heee. Email coming your way, btw.
heee. I know what you mean.
(email coming your way)